Pretty much...however, if the correct decision had been made the penalty would have gone the other way
I have one more thing to add.
Everywhere I am hearing that (mostly from NSW supporters but not entirely) that this years SOO series has been one of the worst for ages. And while Qland supporters are quick to say "well its just because you are losing" let me assure you it isnt. There are 2 main reasons why in my view SOO is facing probably its biggest challenge ever.
1. The imbalance of superstars on one side. Not much needs to be said or can be domne really. Until NSW develop some guys that exceed the superstar status of the likeof Smith, Petro, Ingliss,. Slater etc etc etc (not likely) OR Qslands get injured/move to rugby/ w/e. The forseeable future (say...5-6 years) looks like a continuation of mismatches that will barely be worth tuning into. Its the eqivalance of watching a 1990's WWF match between "The Ultimate Warrior" and ......"Bob Smith". You know whose gonna win, but you vaguely watch anyway just to check out the severity of the beat down. This is a sad spot for SOO to be in
2. DEEP BREATH.....The lack of grrrrrr .....passion and conviction from NSW. They are unlovable right now. They preen and pounce about and get caught up in scandals involving women and generally just dont seem to care that much.
Ive always maitained that "Qlnd Pride" is a crock of shit and I still hold that view. But I think what might have happened is its been banged about so much...... that the NSW players now believe it and have dropped their own pride in their jersey, to the point it IS now true. More power to Qland for their ridiculous pride campaign working by sneaking in the back door I suppose
NSW needs someone to restore that pride. And I dont think Bellamy is the guy to do it. I bagged the appointment of Meninga but I was wrong b/c I didnt realise that at this level coaching acumen isnt as important as getting players up on the day. Mal is the perfect figure to do that with the mana he holds, and few guys in the back room sorting the techical stuff for him. NSW needs a similair hero-coach-leader. But im not sure who that is. NSW heros seem to be good at covering themselves in non-glory (Fittler, Johns)