Fishboy??? Hello??
some good points, however some of your ideas are wack.
1) Jerry collins had a great game, barring one fumble........bear in mind that our most expeienced All Black on the park fumbled an easier ball right after scoring a try. See what happened to Charvis? Number 8 is all about owning your opposite number, and having dominance on the feild in that position, similar to openside flanker. IMO, Jerry did that job, made great yards with the ball in hand, and ran great lines.
Saying he played against avg opposition is a harsh call, charvis is widely respected as a top 8.
2) 70% with the boot. Beleive it or not, have a look at some kicking stats before u slag that off. for a first game in an AB jersey thats a farkin great percentage. Merhtens in his peak doesnt kick much better than that. But then again, Mehrtens aint anywhere near as good a player with theball in hand as I think Dan Carter is, or has the potential to be.
Both carter and spencer created more trys and scoring oppurtunities than merhtens ever can.
Jerry Collins looks like the answer to number 8. Brad Thorn is a wicked impact player, that man is so fucking strong. Kees Mueews....mate...if mitchell picks sommerville over him, I will personally riot down queen street.
Good bye Anton Oliver, I always thought u were not the best hooker in NZ, and its been proven. Mealamu, Tom willis, Shane Carter are all better hookers.
and if someone is listening, please pick Cullen for the world cup, because losing that man to Irish club rugby will be foolish