Blade said:
so in other words, F1 is ghey, and A1 rules

hey, at least its fair.
What you describe Rob about Ferrari and McLaren happens in every motorsport, 1 team comes up with an obvious advantage, another team finds out and protests, so to keep it fair the rules get changed so
I disagree with your first part. No sport was supposed to be fair in the sense that a rugby team can have as many 110kgs as they want, or a team of specialist kckers or runners. It's the balance that makes the difference. And that's what seperates F1 teams from each other. Not just money. Jordan had Mike Gasgoine for a year and their car improved massively without anything like the budget of the top teams (they even won a race with a progression of that car early in the next season).
F1 is inherently different to A1 in that it is supposed to be the forefront of technology. In A1GP the cars are actually irrelevant. They could be racing go-carts or modified mini's. But they chose open-wheelers pretty much to follow the path that F1 has given to technology as the fasted way around a track within standard size, weight, engine capacity, tyres etc.
But A1GP still added a compulsary tyre change to make sure the results were often screwed with. And in only three races this has been proven so.
F1 is not about fairness. ANYONE can possibly come up with a particular development, there's nothing stopping anyone else. So naturally people like Mike Gasgoine and Adrian Newey are always in very high demand. But where are these people in A1GP? Nowhere.
Nothing good for motoring will come from A1GP as it is now. But F1 can be credited with literally hundred of new ideas which have flowed into production cars, not to mention pretty much all other forms of racing. So too have the V8s, Rally cars, motorbikes etc.
I the end a standard car format like A1GP will be a series of 'fair' motoring. These series are never that popular compared to competitive ones. (Even Nascar allows certain improvements to cars despite being basically a stock-car series.)
The problem with F1 is that rule changes which would appear to favour Farrari happen like clock-work, but never the other way around unless as this year by mistake.. which they're being pretty quick about fixing shortly.
BH!
Rob W