I was fourth form when the black album came out.
On my lunch break I borrowed my mates ten speed, raced down to the record store (they were still called that then) and
purchased my pre ordered copy on vinyl.
That evening I put it on and sobbed like a little girl.
The closest anything came to "Metallica" on that album was the intro to "Holier than thou", the intro riff to "Through the Never",
and the intro to "The Struggle Within". Its all intros.... hmmm.
James began his "cowboy" singing, Lars spent too much time admiring his hair, and not enough time coming up with anything
interesting in the beat department.
Kriks solos were still on however.
I dont think it has anything to do with Cliff, like CT said, they gave us Justice after Cliff (Dyers Eve? Holy shit!!), so thats not it.
Let us think about this...
They switched producers from a truly gifted monster guitar tone whiz Flemming Rassmusen, to 80's super glam fucktard
Bob Rock. This I believe is/was the issue. Coupled with Lars being a complete tosser ( I just watched "A Year and a Half" again,
and he was recording his takes with sunglasses on......in the studio where there is no sun........at night.....once again no sun).
Bob is like Grima Wormtonge, always whispering in his ear, playing to his vanities.
This was later proven by a global pertition to have Metallica drop Bob Rock. For Odin's sake, he played bass on St Anger?!?!?!
I understand wanting to write something a bit more simple to play, just for the rock out factor, also the whole "maturing" thing.
But its like a bacon company that makes quality wood smoked bacon, releasing a line of bacon flavored meat in order to make more money.
At least when Slipknot did the "ballad" thing, it was twisted and emotionally heavy (Vermillion, Nameless, Snuff).
Sorry about the rant, it just fucks me off. Lemmy should have bashed them.