2481 of 62450 members online
Coffee Machines 720 GetFrank GymJunkie Menu Mania Snow Surf Varsity

Forgot Your Password? Create Account
[quote]
http://www.arabnews.com/?page=7&section=0&article=34682&d=6&m=11&y=2003

quote:
Is it too early to adopt a revisionist view of the US war in Iraq and for this column to admit its mistake in having vehemently opposed it from the outset?

At issue here is whether the Iraqi people have benefited from the overthrow of the Baathist regime and whether the American occupation will eventually benefit their country even more. I’m convinced — and berate me here from your patriotic bleachers, if you must — that what we have seen in the land between the Tigris and the Euphrates in recent months may turn out to be the most serendipitous event in its modern history.


quote:
No, I don’t believe that by going to war, America had dark designs on Iraq’s oil or pursued an equally dark conspiracy to “help Israel.” I believe that the US, perhaps willy-nilly, will end up helping Iraqis regain their human sanity, their social composure and the national will to rebuild their devastated nation.

And no, it’s not too early to adopt a revisionist view of the US war in Iraq, or too late for a columnist to say he was wrong all along.


The question is; When will our columnists start doing the same?
[quote]
good article, cheers Trapper

Time will tell if Iraq benefits or not though. Lets wait and see before we start the victory parades, until then I'll stick with my opinion that the invasion need not have happened and there were other ways to rid Iraq of Saddam - ways that wouldn't have cost the county so many lives and its infrastructure
[quote]
Shouldn't the heading of this thread read "Arab columnist changes his mind on the war". Wink
[quote]
Good article but theres still a lot of "maybes" and "hopes" and "eventuallys" In there.... in the absense of a plan or timetable what are Iraqi's supposed to think?

I don't think anyone in here thought Hussein was a good man, nor wished he was still in power, it was the way in which the US invaded another sovereign country despite what the rest of the world thought and said.... It set a very dangerous precedent - whats to stop Indonesia reinvading Timor, or China invading Taiwan, Russia invading Chechnya? Those and other countries can justify aggressions using the "if the Americans can do it, why can't we?" excuse...
[quote]
lol phil a. If i may be just as leading here is an example of "Western columnists changing their mind on the war." - and its our very own NZ Herald showing that president Bush has become a joke.

http://www.nzherald.co.nz/storydisplay.cfm?thesection=news&thesubsection=&storyID=3532281&reportID=562588
[quote]
slug what a load of bollocks.

Firstly that columnist isn't changing his mind on anything, he is obviously anti-war. And secondly is not from 'our very own NZ Herald', the article reprinted from the 'oh so unbias' Independent, home of our good friend Mr fisk.
[quote]
Come on trapper, it was a light hearted rebuke to your embellishment that somehow one persons opinion article you present on an arab website (nice that this example is in english for us isnt it) suddenly becomes "Arab coloumnists changing their mind on the war" - heavy emphasis on the COLUMNISTS... with an S. Hardly "bollocks" (quote).
[quote]
haga041 said:
whats to stop Indonesia reinvading Timor, or China invading Taiwan, Russia invading Chechnya? .


Erm... you might want to remove this from your examples aye? Chechnya isn't a sovereign state, it's a region of Russia that rebelled and declared independence. Russia has every right to repress the rebellion and restore order.

wee-ooo wee-ooo
[quote]
fire_engine said:
Erm... you might want to remove this from your examples aye? Chechnya isn't a sovereign state, it's a region of Russia that rebelled and declared independence. Russia has every right to repress the rebellion and restore order.

When do you think Chechnya's history started FE? When it was attached by Russian forces in 1810? When it was merged with the Soviet Union by Stalin in 1934 perhaps? Rolling Eyes
[quote]
Yes, just as the redcoats had every right to suppress the rebellious colonists of America....
[quote]
fire_engine said:
haga041 said:
whats to stop Indonesia reinvading Timor, or China invading Taiwan, Russia invading Chechnya? .


Erm... you might want to remove this from your examples aye? Chechnya isn't a sovereign state, it's a region of Russia that rebelled and declared independence. Russia has every right to repress the rebellion and restore order.

wee-ooo wee-ooo


You know nothing of this conflict so dont embarress yourself by ever talking about it again.
[quote]
bob daktari said:
good article, cheers Trapper

Time will tell if Iraq benefits or not though. Lets wait and see before we start the victory parades, until then I'll stick with my opinion that the invasion need not have happened and there were other ways to rid Iraq of Saddam - ways that wouldn't have cost the county so many lives and its infrastructure



I would love to hear what practical ways you have to get rid of Saddam!