Wipeout said:
Yes, Tindall who is covering him will dance... off the field with a broken face maybe. lol
Btw I haven't seen SBW miss one tackle in ITM Cup. I'm not sure you're right about that fb.
He was pretty brittle going backwards, his inexperience showed out and he panicked a bit. Further, he played the ITM cup at 2nd five, not centre - although I thought that in his one game at centre SBW was outstanding. I have no doubt that if he gets his hit on he'll smash his opponent, but everything happens a lot quicker in tests and being instinctive about the defensive system is all important. If you are still as much a newboy as SBW then you might get caught out of position or panicking hard on defence. Conrad Smith is the chief mid-field defensive organiser in the AB's, Nonu ican be frail on defence - that was shown up yet again in Hong Kong. Having the positionally suspect Nonu with the newboy SBW in midfiled is taking a LOT of risk. And remember we have also lost Cory Jane, a converted fullback with fautless positional play, and replaced him with another big, hard, fast runner.
And that leads me to the other thing that worries me about the balance of this side and that is apart from Carter, who is our kicking option? Having just one kicker makes it easy to attack our defensive kicking game. Jane was the second fullback and kicked a bit. He isn't there. Muliana isn't really a kicker, and Gear and slow-poke Joe? I don't think so.
PS I am not a SBW knocker, I think by the RWC he'll replace either Smith or Nonu in the starting team. I am just wondering about the wisdom of running him out in his first test start against England at Twickers, and if the gamble fails how that might affect him - remember, this selection panel has a habit of doing this and fails more often than not. Hopefully SBW will rise to the occassion and smash the Poms.